Skip to content
California Governor Debate Midterms

California Governor Debate Midterms

www.cnn.com • October 27, 2026

• A heated debate took place between Democrat Xavier Becerra and Republican Steve Hilton, who are vying to replace Gov. Gavin Newsom as the California governor. The candidates sparred on a range of topics, including immigration , affordability and how they would address the impact of AI.

• However, the policies of President Donald Trump and, to a lesser extent, Newsom underpinned most of the debate. Becerra tied Hilton to the president at every possible opportunity as the Republican candidate sought to avoid being linked too closely to Trump while blaming Democrats who have full control of California’s government for the state’s woes.

Our live coverage of tonight’s CNN debate has wrapped. Please scroll through the posts below to learn all that took place on the stage in Los Angeles. You also can read our takeaways here.

President Donald Trump and Gov. Gavin Newsom were certainly present at tonight’s California governor debate — though they weren’t the ones on stage .

Instead, the candidates to succeed Newsom – Democrat Xavier Becerra and Republican Steve Hilton – traded jabs and discussed their vision for California on several key topics, including affordability, immigration, education and vaccines.

The matchup will be a key contest in November, as the winner will take the helm of the country’s most populous state .

Here are the top lines:

The Trump of it all: Throughout the night, Becerra worked to pin Hilton and his proposals to the president, who is not popular in California. In one instance, Becerra said Hilton’s plan to make the first $150,000 of income completely tax-free was a Trump tax policy . Hilton, however, argued that the “quickest way to get more money in people’s pockets is for the government to take less out.”

Hilton pitches for change: Meantime, Hilton oftentimes argued that the issues facing Californians were the result of the last 16 years of Democratic leadership in the state. He sought to paint Becerra as someone who would continue with the status quo, which he said wasn’t working. “All you ever say is Trump, Trump, Trump,” Hilton fired back at his opponent.

Immigration: The candidates sparred on immigration, with Becerra criticizing the Trump administration’s indiscriminate treatment of immigrants at the border or in states by ICE agents. In response, Hilton scrutinized Becerra’s work on immigration as the health and human services secretary in the Biden administration. When pressed on if he would direct law enforcement to cooperate with the Trump administration’s mass deportations, Hilton said he would follow the law.

AI: Asked limits on data centers, Becerra said he would determine where they could be built based on if it would benefit the community . Hilton said he thinks AI companies “may require regulation and legislation ” and called for “an immediate pause” on AI technology in classrooms.

Homelessness: Becerra said he “ demanded accountability ” when attacked on his record on homelessness when he was the state’s attorney general. He said he would clear housing encampments and address mental health and addiction.

Wealth tax: Becerra stood behind his decision not to support the one-time wealth tax on billionaires , even though the proposal is endorsed by the state’s Democratic Party, arguing it’s not the right approach. Hilton said he also opposes the tax and warned it would drive revenue out of the state.

Voting and elections: Hilton said that he has confidence in California’s election systems, but backed his support for a proposition that would require voters to show IDs at the polls. Becerra said the measure would make it harder for people to vote.

Republican Steve Hilton announced he would cap government fees and regulations on a new in California at $50,000, if he were elected governor of the state.

CNN’s David Wright, Tori B. Powell and Aditi Sangal contributed reporting.

Xavier Becerra and Steve Hilton collectively name-dropped President Donald Trump and California Gov. Gavin Newsom more than 50 times in tonight’s debate, highlighting the candidates’ attempts to link each other to the controversial politicians looming over the race.

Becerra said Trump’s name at least 40 times throughout the hourlong debate, as he sought to tie his Republican rival to Trump’s historically unpopular presidency.

Hilton, on the other hand, only said “Trump” three times, all when he told Becerra, “that’s all you say on every question”

Hilton did take aim at Newsom’s governance of California on several occasions, naming him at least eight times as he repeatedly argued that Becerra would be more of the same leadership Californians experienced during his two terms as governor.

Becerra did not say Newsom’s name during the debate.

Closing tonight’s debate, both candidates were asked the lessons they’d take from California’s 176-year history on the anniversary of its founding this month.

But the Republican repeated his argument that Democrats had mismanaged the state, and that rival Xavier Becerra did not deserve a chance to extend his party’s control of the governor’s office.

“That spirit is being crushed by this bloated nanny-state bureaucratic government that Xavier has been a part of for 36 years and would continue. It’s time to try something different,” Hilton said.

Becerra, meanwhile, said California fulfilled the promise of the American dream “more than in any other place in the country. California has thrived. Our dynamism has made us the fourth largest economy in the world.”

He also pointed to his parent’s foundational immigrant experience.

Former US Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra stressed his support for vaccines amid the country’s recent rising measles cases .

“That’s what happens when vaccine-deniers take over,” the Democrat told CNN’s Dana Bash and Jake Tapper tonight.

“And this is what will happen to California if you let someone who is willing to promote that type of attitude become governor of the state of California,” Becerra said. “We can’t reward those who are willing to let families die.”

His, Republican Steve Hilton, also said that he was “pro-vaccine” but suggested that lowering the number of requirements would help increase compliance for “vaccines that are really important for public health.”

Some context: During the Covid-19 pandemic, Becerra was criticized for maintaining a lower profile. Administration officials who were in meetings and virtual calls with the secretary at the time say he took a conflict-averse approach in dealing with the administration’s other Covid-19 leaders. Still, his department coordinated the undertaking of distributing vaccines to hundreds of millions of Americans.

CNN’s Elise Hammond contributed reporting.

Republican Steve Hilton criticized the Democratic Party’s education policy for spending “nearly the highest amount in the entire country for some of the worst results” in California, portraying his opponent Xavier Becerra as a candidate who would do more of the same.

Jumping on that, Becerra said Hilton doesn’t like teachers.

“I believe that the people who are supposed to train our kids should be treated like professionals. They are underpaid compared to professionals with similar education levels,” Becerra said, adding that they should be treated “like real professionals.”

Becerra blamed California’s school problems on too many compliance requirements.

“Before we pass a child on, we’re making sure that they are at grade level. We have to provide the tutoring that they need. We have to start earlier. We’ve started transitional kindergarten, which gets a 4-year-old into our schools. But too often when they’re one, two and three years of age, they’re not being prepared to get into our school system. So I would fight to make sure that we’re working with our teachers because they’re the most important people that will make sure their success for this child,” Becerra said, adding he’ll make sure taxpayer dollars go to public schools.

The candidates running to be California’s governor outlined what they would do to keep film and television production in the state.

This year is on track to become one of the slowest years on record for production and small businesses in California, and workers in the TV and movie industry are struggling to find jobs.

Xavier Becerra, a Democrat, stressed the importance of these jobs the entertainment industry provides.

Last week, another group of bipartisan group of lawmakers introduced a 20% tax credit bill in a bid to bring production back to California.

Steve Hilton, a Republican, sought to blame Democrats who have been running the state for bringing the industry to the “brink of collapse.”

Republican Steve Hilton said that he has confidence in California’s election systems when asked President Donald Trump’s unsubstantiated claims of voter fraud.

“I’ve got confidence in what we saw in the primary and in this process,” Hilton, whom Trump has endorsed, said.

But he seized on remarks from Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass, who recently joked that “we don’t need an election on November 3” because of her high confidence in Democrats’ retaining control of the governor’s office.

“That is the attitude we get from these people who’ve been in charge of our state for 16 years, and they think that they can just do whatever they want, get whatever bad results, the highest taxes in the country for the worst results, taking everybody for granted, taking their votes for granted,” Hilton said.

Becerra, meanwhile, criticized Hilton for backing Proposition 39, an initiative on the ballot this year that would require voters to present a government-issued ID to cast a ballot in person.

“That would make it harder for Californians to vote,” Becerra said of the measure. “We have to all vote no on 39 to send a clear message to Donald Trump and Steve Hilton that we want people to vote.”

Hilton argued back that “there’s a majority in this state who agree that it’s reasonable to show ID when you vote,” and echoed the refrain that “if we vote the same way in this state as we’ve been doing, we’re going to get the same results.”

Xavier Becerra reiterated his position of not backing the one-time wealth tax on billionaires this November, even though a majority of California Democrats support it.

He said the proposal “is not the way to do tax policy,” before touting his experience enacting various tax cuts during his time in politics.

The measure, which will be Proposition 40 on the ballot, would levy a one-time 5% tax on residents with a net worth over $1 billion.

While Becerra said he agrees that billionaires in California are “not paying their fair ,” he said the wealth tax is not the right approach.

The measure would generate tens of billions of dollars that would go toward supporting healthcare programs, schools and food assistance, according to the California Budget & Policy Center . The California Democratic Party has endorsed it.

Becerra previously said he would support other tax proposals on the ballot, including Proposition 3, which provides funding for schools by making higher income state tax rates permanent for high-earners in California, according to the state’s Legislative Analyst’s Office .

Republican Steve Hilton also strongly opposes the billionaire tax. He said at the debate the initiative would drive tax revenue out of the state.

California’s Democratic candidate for governor, Xavier Becerra, defended his record on homelessness while he served as the state’s attorney general.

He vowed to clear homeless encampments if elected and address mental health and addiction.

“We have to be serious tacking that,” Becerra said.

He also said he’d work with cities and counties to house unsheltered people.

As the candidates for California governor debated over their positions on immigration, Democrat Xavier Becerra rallied against the Trump administration’s indiscriminate treatment of immigrants at the border or in states by ICE agents. In quick response, Republican Steve Hilton criticized Becerra’s work on immigration as health and human services secretary in the Biden administration.

Becerra faced scrutiny for his department’s handling of a record surge of unaccompanied migrant minors who arrived at the US-Mexico border. The children were placed in HHS custody, with some languishing in emergency facilities .

In response, Becerra said those are “Trump talking points” before defending his record.

“[Trump] used to put kids in cages. He used to separate those children from their parents. We changed all that. I am proud of the record in all my life of working on immigration and in protecting immigrant children,” Becerra added, saying he does not support ICE raids and actions that separate kids from their parents.

Steve Hilton and Xavier Becerra exchanged sharp words during a debate over immigration policy.

Hilton was pressed on whether he would direct California law enforcement to cooperate with the Trump administration’s mass deportations. He noted California’s sanctuary laws, but said that “there is scope within the law” for cooperation “on a long list of categories, specific crimes, and specific circumstances.”

Becerra criticized his rival, referencing Hilton’s own immigrant experience. “California welcomed you into California, and you welcomed ICE mercenaries into our state in return,” he argued. “How do you square that?”

If elected, Becerra would be California’s first Latino governor in more than 150 years.

Hilton shot back, “You’re not enforcing, and your party isn’t enforcing California law as it is now. And what a disgraceful remark that was!”

In another contentious back-and-forth moment during Wednesday’s debate, Steve Hilton claimed Xavier Becerra had “never created a job” in his 36 years as a politician.

Hilton also referenced a report that former domestic policy adviser Susan Rice, who worked with Becerra during President Joe Biden’s administration, called the candidate an “idiot” and a “bitch-ass” in private.

Hilton’s stemmed from a 2024 Axios report alleging Rice had called Becerra those names. At the time, a spokesperson told Axios she “categorically denies” the reporting.

On X, Hilton posted a clip of the moment from Wednesday’s debate and linked to a website his campaign created, called bitchassbecerra.com.

Democrat Xavier Becerra said he would work with local communities to enforce limits and regulations on data centers, at a time when Americans across the country are expressing concerns their impacts.

“The standard,” Becerra said, would be determining if the data center benefits the community.

“If all you’re going to do is rob their energy and electricity and their water, that’s not a good deal,” he said.

Conversely, Becerra said he would also consider the opposite scenario. “If someone wants to come in and build a data center that creates more jobs in the community, adds more energy to our grid and it actually protects and adds more water capacity, then let’s talk.”

Some context: Nationally, the expansion of data centers to support AI technology has sparked concern among Americans.

Just today, Senate Democrats blocked a GOP-led bill to combat rising energy costs driven by the surge of data centers. Democrats said the language was weak and lacked enforcement mechanisms.

The bill would require state regulators to “consider” adopting a proposed federal standard that would require data center companies to cover their costs to the energy grid, rather than passing it off to consumers.

Former Fox News host Steve Hilton said he thinks AI companies “may require regulation and legislation.”

Hilton also called for “an immediate pause” on AI technology in classrooms.

This week President Donald Trump said top tech executives signed a new commitment aimed at better “self-policing” their companies’ AI models, arguing that the light-touch approach represents the best way to balance safety concerns with his desire to accelerate a technology that he’s dubbed “Super Intelligence.”

The president later posted the accord on Truth Social , which detailed four steps that all the companies agreed to take: implement internal controls to ensure models are adhering to appropriate standards on cybersecurity; empower an internal team to ensure controls, monitoring and detection are working as intended; partner with an external operator to independently assess the models; and designate an “independent committee of the board of directors” to receive those reports and make sure any problems are addressed.

CNN’s Hadas Gold and Adam Cancryn contributed reporting.

Fielding the first question at tonight’s debate, Democrat Xavier Becerra said he disagreed with Republican Steve Hilton’s proposal to cut state taxes as Californians struggle with high cost of living.

“What he would do is he would damage our state even further,” Becerra said, asked Hilton’s proposal to eliminate state taxes on the first $150,000 of income, and a flat 8% tax rate on income above that level.

Hilton began by jabbing at Becerra’s campaigning — remarking, “I just want to say thank you to CNN for bringing Xavier out of hiding. He’s barely been seen in public since the primary four months ago.”

Becerra rejected Hilton’s argument, saying his proposal would favor wealthy Californians.

“You’re going to hear a lot of stories, a lot of new math, a lot of alternative facts from Steve Hilton,” he challenged. The math doesn’t add up.”

Republican Steve Hilton said he would cap government fees and regulations on a new in California at $50,000 if he were to be elected governor of the state.

He also expressed opposition to the construction of apartment buildings in suburban areas and proposed the development of 10 new cities in the state.

Meanwhile, Democrat Xavier Becerra reiterated his goal to “at least double the rate of building homes” to address the housing gap.

At the top of CNN’s California governor debate tonight, Xavier Becerra worked to tie his opponent, Republican Steve Hilton, to some of President Donald Trump’s policies.

“Isn’t it the definition of insanity? You do the same thing over and over again, expecting different results,” he added.

Hilton, a Trump supporter who also has his endorsement, has pointed to other states where the cost of living is lower. The Republican candidate has been blaming Democrats for the state’s high cost of living, while Becerra has been blaming the Trump administration.

One of Hilton’s proposals is to make the first $150,000 of income completely tax-free for all California residents.

Democrat Xavier Becerra and Republican Steve Hilton are taking the debate stage in Los Angeles to make their pitch on why they should be elected the governor of the country’s most populous state.

The question posed to voters in this race is whether they lay blame at the feet of the Democrats in charge for the direction the state is going, or a Republican Party led by President Donald Trump.

Polls show Becerra, a former secretary of Health and Human Services, with a significant lead over Hilton, an ex-Fox News host and British political operative.

Extracted Entities