Skip to content
Experts warn of 'shockingly awful' security against cyber attacks

Experts warn of 'shockingly awful' security against cyber attacks

Thenational.Scot • November 15, 2026

A CYBER security expert has warned that "shockingly awful" security systems could be leaving Scotland's healthcare open to attack by increasingly unethical cybercriminals.

A National Cyber Security Centre review in November cautioned that attacks are increasing in speed and severity across the UK, with public sector and critical infrastructure among the most heavily targeted.

While many attacks are not publicised, just last month, Scotland's health boards, multiple councils and the Care Inspectorate immediately took their websites offline following a serious cyber security alert.

The perpetrators are most commonly groups from Russia, China, Iran and North Korea, increasingly using artificial intelligence.

On the preparedness of Scotland's public services against these threats, Dr Daniel Thomas , a senior lecturer in computer and information sciences at the University of Strathclyde , said: "The security provided by many systems is shockingly awful; there have always been loads of vulnerabilities."

He added that Scotland's health-care system could be at risk in a way that would have been possible before, but perhaps not attempted.

"There have been several instances of health boards having, for example, ransomware attacks that are being targeted by cybercriminals because they have valuable data people's health and personal information.

"There's an opportunity to try to ransom either the health board or the patients to prevent access. In terms of kind of financial losses, I think ransomware is probably the most impactful and the cause of the most harm.

"It can be [obtaining] personal information and then threatening to release it, but also the destruction of data," Thomas added.

Not only are attacks becoming quicker, but they're targeting areas of society which may have previously been avoided for fear of repercussions or avoided by foreign actors for ethical reasons.

Experts have warned that Scotland's public services are vulnerable to attack. (Image: Archive)

Thomas continued: "There was a point in time when cybercriminals would avoid hospitals and healthcare settings because it was having a direct impact on patients, and that's not nice.

"But that kind of cybercriminal ethics has slipped away a lot more in recent years, particularly when we're considering people operating out of places like Russia.

"Before, they might have pressure from their own domestic authorities that they shouldn't be doing that kind of thing, going after hospitals, but that's not the case anymore. We're in a much more aggressive adversarial relationship with Russia."

Heather Burns, a tech policy and digital rights specialist, says there's an important but often overlooked problem with hybrid attack defences: the human element.

She said: "Scotland's public sector is absolutely shambolic when it comes to the first line of defence against cyberattacks, which is the human factor."

She referenced an incident from December 2023 to January 2024 in which a man had fraudulently posed as a medical student at an Aberdeen hospital for over a month before he was caught, accessing restricted medical files and wards.

"Likewise, there is a loophole in the Health and Care (Staffing) (Scotland) Act 2019 which exempts both NHS-employed and agency-outsourced administrative staff from being required to have any qualifications, vetting or training on anything, including data protection and information security.

"This means that the people who deal with patient data as their core job function are, from a cybersecurity perspective, people who absolutely should not be allowed to go anywhere near it."

The concerns come at a time when ministers are planning for a restructuring of Scotland's public sector, including changing the number of health boards to two and reducing the number of councils.

Burns added: "Whatever the Scottish Government decides to do, whether that is reducing the number of organisations or keeping them as they are, thinking of cybersecurity only in terms of networks and infrastructure will continue to perpetuate the shameful failure of imagination which causes the majority of cybersecurity incidents in the public sector."

Thomas warns that it's not just health boards that are at risk.

He says it can affect any public service "that is using the internet", adding "it depends on the extent to which the systems are reliant on working internet connectivity to operate".

"Schools use computers and understand that if there are some attacks that cause computers to stop working for a while, that will be disruptive, but you'll still be able to teach people in the way that you have for hundreds of years.

"It will be annoying, but you keep going. Whereas if you've got patient record systems that are entirely digital and they're not working, it's more disruptive in a healthcare system."

The threats to Scotland come at a time when Europe is grappling with increasingly severe hybrid warfare attacks, including recent bomb threats disrupting travel across the continent.

Last month, attackers targeted fridges in France, turning units to as high as 50 degrees in an attempt to spoil food. Then last week, food businesses in around nine European countries were targeted with a similar attack.

Thomas added: "The fridges thing in France, these kinds of things have been possible for decades; the security systems are shockingly awful, and there have always been loads of vulnerabilities.

"There are steps you hear that the UK and EU have taken in recent years to try and improve on that, but fundamentally, many internet-connected systems don't have the basics of cyber security and never have.

"And the only thing that's been stopping these attacks is that no-one has cared enough to do it. We've had the doors open for years, and no-one's bothered to come through them.

"Now people are coming all the way through, and we suddenly have to go around and fix all these problems."

Public Services Delivery Scotland have been approached for .

Extracted Entities

Attack Types (1)

Companies (1)

Industries (2)