Skip to content
Smart Knee Implants Draw Lawsuit Over Unconsented Data-Transmitting Devices

Smart Knee Implants Draw Lawsuit Over Unconsented Data-Transmitting Devices

First seen 22 Nov 2026, 13:12 UTC • •

Article Content

Browse articles
ThreatCluster AI
ThreatCluster •November 22, 2026 at 13:13 UTC
  • •Two patients are suing after allegedly receiving Zimmer Biomet Persona IQ smart knee implants without authorization to transmit data.
  • •Plaintiff Steve Russak alleges lack of informed consent and says he could not get an MRI due to device compatibility issues.
  • •Zimmer Biomet and Canary Medical deny the allegations and attribute any damages to other parties or unforeseeable causes.
  • •Researchers reportedly say the usefulness of smart implants is unproven, while Medicare and private insurers pay for monitoring.
  • •A hearing in Russak's case is scheduled for December.

LA Times (via KFF Health News) reports that patient Steve Russak, 70, woke from knee replacement surgery last year to find he had received a Zimmer Biomet Persona IQ "smart knee" with a battery, sensors and transmitter, and is now suing the surgeon, Zimmer Biomet and Canary Medical. Russak alleges the implantation was unauthorized and that he was not given the option to opt out of data collection or decline the device, claiming lack of informed consent. He says the device now causes compatibility problems, including reportedly being unable to get an MRI. The article states that researchers say the usefulness of such devices is unproven, while Medicare and private insurers pay doctors to monitor them. Russak has dropped the fraud and breach of fiduciary duty claims against the doctor but continues on other grounds; a hearing is scheduled for December. Zimmer and Canary have both filed responses denying the allegations and offering defenses including that damages stem from another party or from unforeseeable actions or reactions. Zimmer spokesperson Troy Kirkpatrick said data transmission requires patient authorization at account setup and that nearly 90% of surveyed patients said they would choose a device with remote monitoring again. The article reports a second patient is also suing over a similar allegation. The doctor had not responded to requests for comment as of publication. The 2021 press release describes FDA De Novo authorization of the Persona IQ tibial extension sensor.

Start a free Starter trial for enhanced analysis

Ask AI about this cluster

Timeline

2021-08-30
FDA De Novo authorization announced for Persona IQ
Zimmer Biomet and Canary Medical announced FDA authorization to market the tibial extension sensor for Persona IQ, described as the first smart knee cleared for total knee replacement.
PRNewswire
2026-11-22
Lawsuits over smart knee implants reported
LA Times and KFF Health News report on the suit, with Zimmer and Canary filing denials and a December hearing scheduled.
LA Times
Recent
Russak receives smart knee during surgery
Russak, 70, reportedly woke from knee replacement surgery last year to find a Persona IQ implant and texts from Zimmer Biomet asking him to use an app.
LA Times

More articles in this cluster (5)

Following this threat?

Track Canary Medical in your own feed — you're alerted when they show up in new reporting, leak sites or exploitation.

Free account · no card needed

Common questions

Are patients with Persona IQ implants required to share data?
Zimmer Biomet says transmission requires patient authorization at account setup, while plaintiff Russak alleges he was never offered the option to opt out or decline the device. The articles do not resolve this dispute.
Has the FDA authorized the Persona IQ device?
Yes. Zimmer Biomet and Canary Medical announced FDA De Novo authorization for the Persona IQ tibial extension sensor in August 2021.
What is the status of the litigation?
Russak continues to sue on grounds including lack of informed consent, and both companies have denied the allegations; a hearing is scheduled for December.